Saatva vs Beautyrest Black Mattress

Saatva vs Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress

Saatva Mattress

Hybrid Mattress

4-5
Saatva Mattress
  • Dual coil structure offers exceptional support and alignment
  • Available in 3 firmness levels
  • 15-year non-prorated warranty
  • Free white glove delivery and setup
  • 120 day home trial

Beautyrest Black Calista

Innerspring Mattress

4-5
Simmons Beautyrest Black Calista Mattress Review
  • Superior support and body alignment
  • Sleeps cool - advanced design dissipates heat
  • Excellent edge support
  • Low motion transfer
  • Solid company reputation
BestSlumber may receive a small commission on sales of some of the featured products throughout the site. It is our mission to provide unbiased insight on how to find you the best possible sleep solutions.

Overview

We compared these two mattress models to help you decide which is right for you. These mattresses have their distinct differences and similarities. This guide will help walk you through their construction, comfort feel, what we liked and what we didn’t like about each bed.


Quick Comparison

Name Type Price Delivery Trial Warranty Rating
Saatva Mattress Hybrid Mattress $1,099 Free white glove 120 days 15 years 93
Beautyrest Black Calista Innerspring Mattress $1,799 Free white glove delivery 120 days 10 years 93

Comfort

We rated these mattresses comfort feels on a scale of 1-10, 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest.

Saatva Mattress Comfort Scale

  • Softest
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3Plush Soft
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6Luxury Firm
  • 7
  • 8Firm
  • 9
  • 10
  • Firmest

Beautyrest Black Calista Comfort Scale

  • Softest
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4Plush
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8Extra Firm
  • 9
  • 10
  • Firmest

Construction

Saatva Mattress Construction

Saatva 14.5” Mattress

The cover – Saatva’s cover is made from 100% GOTS certified organic cotton. The surface is a soft, breathable, and durable cover made with a natural thistle flame barrier, which doesn’t use any chemical fire retardant sprays. The cover also has a Guardin® botanical antimicrobial fabric treatment, and an organic damask bronze trim as a finishing touch.

Comfort foam – CertiPUR-US certified polyurethane-based foams provide the comfort layer. Depending on the firmness, density will range from 1.5 lb – 1.8 lb per cubic foot. The firmer the mattress, the denser the foam. Saatva’s foam pillow top is sewn under the cotton cover for a smooth, clean look.

Saatva Mattress Diagram

Dual coil support – The top layer is a 4” 14.5 gauge, individually pocketed coil system. It’s designed for better body contour and reduced motion transfer. Total coil count of this layer is 884 for a standard queen. The 7.5” base layer utilizes 416 13 gauge coils for added support and structure. All coils are foam encased for better edge support.

Lumbar zone support technology – The center of the mattress uses active wire support for additional spinal alignment.

Saatva 11.5” Mattress

The 11.5″ model has a reduced base support layer of 4″ compared to the 14.5″ model’s 7″ base. The reduced base size allows the mattress to function with an adjustable base. It does, however, reduce the overall structure of the mattress slightly. That said, it’s still more than adequate for most sleepers.

Add An Adjustable Base

(Option available with 11.5” mattress only)

The Lineal™ Adjustable Base by Saatva is compatible with the original Saatva and Zenhaven mattress.

Combine 2 Twin XL mattresses and adjustable bases for side by side individual adjustability.

Saatva Lineal Adjustable Mattress Base

Saatva Mattress

Saatva Mattress

Hybrid Mattress

4-5

Beautyrest Black Calista Construction

Simmons Beautyrest Black utilizes a triple wrapped braided coil structure. This unique designs sets an industry standard for support and responsiveness. Varying densities and thicknesses of cool sleeping memory foam are used to create distinctively different comfort feels.

Surfacecool Plush Fiber

This layer of vertically oriented fibers is designed to dissipate body heat away from the sleeping surface.

Beautyrest cover material

Geltouch Foam

A soft gel foam that helps provide comfort, support, airflow and breathability.

Comfort Foams

High quality comfort foams in different levels of plushness used in various constructions to create comfort preferences. Available in firm, luxury firm and plush comfort levels.

Micro Diamond Memory Foam

This foam utilizes the conductive properties of diamond particles
which are designed to move heat away from the body.

Advanced Pocketed Coil Technology

A triple wrapped braided coil design offers added structural integrity to this mattress. This feature is unique to the Beautyrest Black lineup. It works to provide individualized back support, ease of movement, and pressure point relief throughout the night.

Beautyrest Black front view

Energy Foams

This durable foam utilized below the coil unit helps create a supportive,
durable foundation for the no-flip mattress design.

Simmons Beautyrest Black Calista Mattress Review

Beautyrest Black Calista

Innerspring Mattress

4-5

Our Rating

We scored these mattresses over a variety of important factors to be considered when purchasing a new bed. All scores are a numerical value out of 100.

Rating Saatva Mattress Beautyrest Black Calista
Overall Rating 93 93
Support 95 100
Pressure Relief 90 90
Motion Transfer 75 90
Ease of Movement 95 90
Sleeps Cool 90 90
Off-Gassing 95 90
Durability 100 100
Edge Support 95 100
Sex Friendly 90 90
Trial Period 90 90
Warranty 100 90
Delivery 100 100
Money Value 100 100

Saatva Mattress Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Support: Dual coil system provides superior support and structure
  • Three firmness options for varying comfort preferences
  • Sleeps cool - Breathable cotton cover and coil system allow for smooth air passage
  • No chemical fire retardants
  • 15-year non-prorated warranty
  • Free white glove delivery and setup

Cons:

  • Motion transfer may be more noticeable than other options
  • 14.5” mattress is not adjustable friendly
  • Delivery delays: While Saatva’s overall service record has been excellent, A small number of delivery delays have been reported.
Saatva Mattress

Saatva Mattress

Hybrid Mattress

4-5

Beautyrest Black Calista Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Excellent support - Premium coil system and dense foams create great body aligning support.
  • Individually pocketed coils reduce motion transfer. Couples feel their partner's movements less which promotes more restful nights.
  • High density memory foam reduces pressure points and limits motion detection.
  • Sleeps cool: Breathable Gel Touch and Micro Diamond memory foam make for cooler sleep environment.
  • Superior edge support: Great edge support creates a consistent comfort feel across the entire mattress. It also eliminates feeling as though you are rolling off the bed.
  • Consumer confidence: Simmons is one of the most respected names in the bedding industry.

Cons:

  • Limited firmness range: With only two firmness options, the Calista will not satisfy everyone's comfort need. Fortunately, The Beautyrest Black lineup offers great diversity. From very firm to super soft options.
  • Price: Dollar for dollar, the Calista is an exceptional value. Yet, at a starting price of $1,799 for a queen, this mattress may be too expensive for some shoppers.
Simmons Beautyrest Black Calista Mattress Review

Beautyrest Black Calista

Innerspring Mattress

4-5

Pricing

Saatva Mattress Pricing

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 38" x 75" $599, with foundation - $758
Twin XL 38" x 80" $749, with foundation - $908
Full 54" x 75" $999, with foundation - $1,208
Queen 60" x 80" $1,099, with foundation - $1,398
King 76" x 80" $1,499, with foundation - $1,817
Cal King 72" x 84" $1,499, with foundation - $1,817

Check out SaatvaMattress.com

Beautyrest Black Calista Pricing

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 38" x 75" N/A
Twin XL 38" x 80" Firm or Plush $1,299
Full 54" x 75" Firm or Plush $1,669
Queen 60" x 80" Firm or Plush $1,799
King 76" x 80" Firm or Plush $2,299
Cal King 72" x 84" Firm or Plush $2,299

Check out Beautyrest.com


Saatva vs Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress

Leave a Comment